• The More Things Change, the More They Stay the Same: Examining the MLP Yield to Treasuries Spread

    07/12/17 | Karyl Patredis

    Do you have an updated yield spread chart?

    Almost two years ago, I wrote a post about the Alerian MLP Index (AMZ) yield compared to the yield of the 10-year Treasury. On July 24th, 2015, the 10-year Treasury closed at 2.27%, while the AMZ closed at 6.96%. The spread was 470 bps and there was lots of speculation about why the yield spread was well above the 10-year median of 337 bps. At the time, we wondered if it could be that investors were pricing MLPs with the expectation that the 10-year Treasury rate would increase significantly over the next year.

    Jump forward to present day. On June 20, 2017, the 10-year Treasury closed at 2.30%, while the AMZ closed at 7.13%. This means the yield spread is a little higher today than a couple of years ago, but really, things aren’t that much different today than they were the last time I examined yield spread.

    Although the snapshots between now and then look relatively similar, a lot happened over the last two years. If you’re wondering about that spike in the chart in early 2016, that reflects the day MLPs hit their low of the recent energy cycle. The AMZ was yielding 12.01% on that day and the 10-year Treasury was at 1.66%! That’s a spread of 1035 bps for those of you playing along at home. The rolling 10-Yr median AMZ spread to treasuries has increased by 70 bps and the lowest spread we’ve seen over the past two years was 413 bps in January 2017.

    So, what does all of this mean?

    Well, it could mean a few things. One is that investors are still expecting interest rates to rise. This isn’t an empty expectation. Economists do believe we’ll see a bump in the 10-year Treasury by the end of 2017, but it won’t be too earth-shattering. They say we can expect an increase of about 10 bps.

    It could also mean that MLPs are undervalued. Some say that even with oil hovering around $50 per barrel, there is an increasing need for midstream services. Due to new technologies and improved efficiencies, wells are being drilled two times faster and seeing three times as much production. Is it possible that investors aren’t fully grasping the extent of midstream services that will be needed to get oil to market?

    Or possibly, this is the new normal. The chart below shows ten years of yield spread history. Each bar represents a spread grouping and the y-axis reflects percentages of time. While spreads within the 3.01%-3.50% were still seen most frequently, it is becoming increasingly more likely to see spreads in the 4.51%-5.00% range. In 2015, spreads in this group only occurred about 10% of the time, now we’re looking at 13.2% of the time.

    Is it conceivable that this is just the spread MLP investors can expect in the near future? Most can agree there are much worse things than 7% yields!

    As we move forward in an ever-changing financial climate and oil price environment, we will look at the effects of interest rate increases with fresh eyes. Alerian’s Director of Research will release an update to our existing white paper discussing MLPs and interest rates in the next few weeks. Stay tuned!